(Or the Precarious Balance between War and Peace
and How It Works)
It starts innocently enough. An interesting
movie. A good series. A book you cannot put down. A day or two to ponder the
things, the necessary internet search that follows, and you’re hooked, yet all
is still well until that one crucial moment: you realise there are others like you.
Nowadays, ‘fandoms’—consisting of fan [fanatic] plus the suffix -dom, as in kingdom,
freedom, etc.; a term used to refer to a subculture composed of fans
characterised by a feeling of sympathy and camaraderie with others who share a
common interest—are a common
occurrence. Being a part of a fandom is great. It doesn’t end with “oh, we have
a common interest, nice. So, what else do you like to do?” Seeing/reading the
movie/series/book is just the beginning.
It is, perhaps, a bit hard to explain the
experience to somebody who has never been interested in those kind of things.
In a way, belonging to a fandom is similar to being a part of a social network,
only there is no official way to ‘log in.’ Of course there are websites where
fans gather, such as tumblr or livejournal, but they are by no means limited
to the aforementioned topics. The simplest way to know you’ve entered a fandom
is probably asking yourself how much you’re interested in the thing. If the
answer is a lot…
A fandom’s ability to turn a single detail into
science is—in my experience—incredible. There is hardly anything that goes unnoticed,
especially in the bigger fandoms, and this leads to the important part:
discussions. Sharing and comparing beliefs. Analysing things. It’s a proof that
the hysterical (or not so hysterical) ‘fangirls’ (and ‘fanboys,’ it depends on
the fandom) think. They have things
to tell, things that are worth hearing. No, they don’t obediently take whatever
production companies dish out to them. Mistakes are criticized, unmoral things
are judged, good characterisation is praised. Fans are not just ‘nerds’ who
know nothing but their own computer screen.
However, not everything is all rainbows and
flowers all the time. There are the so-called ‘fandom wars,’
not so much real
wars as they are competitions meant to compare the popularity or the size of
certain fandoms, and while there are some fandoms where staying neutral among
all the zealous fans and stubborn haters is hard (*cough* Twilight *cough*),
mostly this isn’t the case. Members of one fandom mostly leave other fans
alone. Many people (if not the majority) participate in more than one fandom at
a time anyway. Though rest assured that, if attacked, a fandom will stand
together and fight.
But fandom wars are not the only
battles out there, nor are they the most important ones. The real fights happen
within the fandoms.
You think if two people are fascinated by the
same thing, they are necessarily going to get along? Wrong. There are as many
opinions as there are fans, and they are bound to clash. Firstly, there is ‘shipping.' Everybody has their OTPs (=one
true pairing; see the shipping link); of course these are always a hot topic.
Secondly, opinions about a certain character differ, and this is where it
really comes to fighting. Most people are polite (or try to be) when expressing
their opinions, so yes, etiquette exists on the internet (and I feel sorry for
anyone who claims otherwise, because, obviously, they have only ever had bad
experiences with the web), but there is a point where it becomes impossible to
defend one person without insulting another. It’s sad. Mostly, it’s not even
done on purpose. Unless, of course, the whole thing escalates, replies are
exchanged, and everyone ends up fed up and sulking. It happens. It is happening, continually.
Why am I writing about this? I don’t know. I
guess it hurts when your views and beliefs get insulted (or when one group
keeps insisting the other side claims something they have never claimed… But
that’s details, and I’ll stop before I start ranting…). It’s not all bad,
though. There are people who have the same opinions and beliefs—well, hello,
bonding. Also, like in every war, there are battles, and then there is peace.
Give the fans a common enemy, and they will stand united again.
(I hope.)
~S
What an interesting topic to write about! I’m flashed. I was also part of a fandom (not only one…) and somehow we all are, when we are interested in something. So, I know how fan wars start and how fandoms can compete with each other… It’s a little bit sad, because they share a common interest and only due to a little difference (e.g. shpping and pairs!) wars have started! Sadly but true…
ReplyDeleteWhich fandoms, if you don't mind my asking? My obsession is MCU...
ReplyDelete